Thoughts on A Message from NaNoWriMo
I got an email today from the National Novel Writing Month head office, as I suspect many did. I have feelings. And questions.
First, I genuinely believe someone in the office is panicking and backtracking and did not endorse all that was said and done in the last month. From what I understand, the initial generative AI comments were not fully endorsed by all NaNo staff and board members, or even known in advance. It’s got to be rough to find out your organization kinda called people with disabilities incapable of writing a story on their own, and overtly called people with ethics racists and ablists, by reading the reactions on social media — and then your organization’s even worse counter-reactions on social media.
I still think NaNoWriMo has a good mission and many people in it with good goals.
But I think NaNoWriMo is SERIOUSLY missing a point in its performative progressivism. (For the record, I actually support many progressive policies, and I support many of the same concepts NaNoWriMo claims to support, and I applaud providing materials to underfunded schools and support to marginalized groups historically not producing as many writers, etc. The issue here is not “whether or not woke is okay” — it’s whether or not the virtue signaling is still in line with the core mission.)
Also, honesty. (That’s below.)
Thoughts on A Message from NaNoWriMo