On Spoilers. (I Hate Them.)

Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back

Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

A 2011 psychology experiment indicates that spoilers don’t ruin a story, but rather enhance it.

With all respect, in this regard psychology has its headlight plugged firmly into its tail-lamp. And that’s coming from someone who makes her day job in psychology and behavior, so you know I feel pretty strongly about this.

The experiment showed subjects short stories with and without spoilers, and asked subjects to rate their enjoyment reading. The study showed “significant preference” for the spoiled versions.

I don’t have the particulars of how the study was conducted, but I have a few guesses as to why researchers got the answers they did.

“I Hate Spoilers, Jock! I Hate ‘Em!”

I had a friend who didn’t mind spoilers. She knew I worked actively to avoid them, but that didn’t stop her from detailing the big reveal in the book she had just finished — the end of a series I was partway through.

I had a physical reaction to hearing her ruin the mystery for me. Six more books’ worth of overarching plot were vaporized in a sentence. Though there was nothing wrong with the story itself, the cheating experience was so jarring for me that I have not, in the years since, picked up another book in the series.

Even talking non-specifically around a spoiler can be a spoiler; to the naive viewer, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is going to be a great Western. Once someone starts talking about, “Just wait for the surprise!” though, the effect is already gone. (I’m comfortable using this example because you should have already seen it. If you haven’t, go complete your education.)

What Do We Like?

Many stories with surprise or ironic endings are renowned as much for their subtlety and careful plotting as for the ending. There’s no doubt that an awareness of the ending can add a whole new dimension to the reading experience, as we revel in not only what the author did, but how they did it.

But we can’t fully appreciate the joke until we’ve laughed at the punchline. A well-crafted plot twist is better when viewed from both sides, I think. And I’m not alone; haven’t you read a really great twist, one that, in hindsight, was perfectly clear, but which kept you suspended until the reveal? Isn’t that how we know it was a really great twist?

One of my very favorite reader reviews was a comment on Facebook — “as soon as I finished, I immediately started over to look for all the clues.” She read the book twice, with a different lens the second time. Two experiences for the price of one.

The overall findings are consistent with the experience most of us have had: A favorite tale can be re-read multiple times with undiminished pleasure. A beloved movie can be watched again and again.

Yes, but — the favorites one watches again and again typically aren’t valued for the surprise endings, but for the overall process.

Cover of "The Princess Bride (20th Annive...

What brilliant text work. Cover of 20th Anniversary Edition. Cover via Amazon.

Look at The Princess Bride — no one watches this cult film for the 47th time because they were shocked, shocked! to find that Wesley and Roberts were the same! (Seriously, it’s not even a pretense in the film.) No one was in terrible suspense as to whether Iñigo would find and overcome his lifelong nemesis. No, it’s a blatant fairy tale and we’re under no illusions whether we’re going to have a happy ending. We’re enjoying the ride.

But wait, you say; doesn’t that just prove the point? People don’t want or need the surprise or suspense? Not quite — I’m saying that if it’s a good story, we love all the parts, even once we know the trick of it. Knowing the skill involved in a magic show does not make me appreciate the showmanship less. Knowing the phenomenal effort a ballerina puts into her dance makes me appreciate her seemingly careless grace all the more. I know how Casablanca ends, but I watch it again for the fascinating interplay of characters.

And for every film we watch again for the fantastic dramatic tension, there’s another we don’t need to ever watch again. Knowing the ending doesn’t make it better.

On the flip side, a really good whodunit can keep readers hanging on the edge of the page, and then they can read it again, this time catching all the clues and appreciating the careful jigsaw work in the foundation.

The key is right in the linguistics — it’s called a reveal. It’s not called a bit-of-vital-information-the-reader-already-was-told.

And if the reader were supposed to know, why wouldn’t the author put that right up front? Let us see the murderer’s face in the first chapter, and then we can follow the detective to find out if he’s clever? Hm? Oh, right, because that would usually be boring.

Why did readers tell researchers they preferred the spoiled story?

I have a couple of guesses. First is part of the inherent attraction of knowing any surprise — the knowing. It’s the difference between being the subject of a prank (not fun) and watching someone get pranked (fun).

A reader who figures out a twist gets to feel smug and clever (I guessed the twist in The Usual Suspects before the reveal, and boy, was it sad I was alone and couldn’t brag to anyone), and having a spoiler gives the reader that prize for free. Does it feel good to be in the know? Of course it does.

But, if I may reference other psychology, a prize is better when it is earned. A rat earning cocaine shows greater dopamine signaling in the brain than a rat receiving cocaine for free (here and here and more generally here). Will it take the free hit? Of course. Will it even find it preferable to take the free hit instead of working for it? Often — but often not. But which is the better trip in the end?

And some readers prefer security; they don’t want to invest themselves in a story which isn’t going to come out the “right way.” Knowing the ending gives them some emotional distance or a life ring of hope if the story gets rough.

The other reason readers might find spoilers pleasing is identified right in the article:

It’s also possible that it’s “easier” to read a spoiled story. Other psychological studies have shown that people have an aesthetic preference for objects that are perceptually easy to process.

“So it could be,” said Leavitt, a psychology doctoral student at UC San Diego, “that once you know how it turns out, it’s cognitively easier….”

Yep, it all comes down to laziness. We don’t have to keep track of spoiled stories. And that makes me terribly sad, actually.

poster for Citizen Kane

poster for Citizen Kane (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

I Hate Spoilers

I was clever or lucky enough to experience some classics early in life, before they were spoiled for me. And as I’ve compared my experiences with friends who never got the opportunity to discover these plots for themselves, I’m very glad I did.

I watched Citizen Kane before Rosebud was in the Animaniacs opening song, and I remember the slow squeeze of my heart as the film’s meaning settled inexorably on me.

I read Murder on the Orient Express unspoiled and lost whole nights trying to work out the impossible puzzle by flashlight.

And I watched The Empire Strikes Back before I encountered the Big Reveal in pop culture, and I can still recall the jaw-dropping intensity of that experience.

I was older, but yes, it felt a lot like this:

Is there really someone who wants to take that moment away from that kid? Really? Because I have a pit full of were-badgers who would love to discuss it with you.

And even after a reveal? Well, the experience isn’t over — we have to process it, evaluate it, wrestle with it.

Do you remember all the Harry Potter finale hoopla? The parties, the forum debates, the “Snape: Friend or Foe?” suspense? Do you think fans would have been just as happy and excited if Rowling had announced before release, “Yeah, just so you know, here’s what’s going on”?

The point is, while some folks might like the security or easy sense of victory a spoiler gives, others of us really enjoy the suspense or the puzzle. And a spoiler, well, spoils that.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Announcement: a new book is coming soon
Happy Halloween!
Bookmark the permalink.

24 Comments

  1. Yes, yes, yes, yes… and yes!!!!! There’s a reason they’re called SPOILers!!

  2. Ditto — I HATE spoilers. I’m still upset that I had most of the classic film reveals (Citizen Kane, The Empire Strikes Back, etc.) ruined for me before I saw them; I’ve gotten to the point where I’ve stopped reading the descriptions of famous movies I haven’t seen. I really enjoy a good twist ending!

  3. Pingback: Book Covers & Badasses - Laura VanArendonk Baugh

  4. Pingback: Storylines and Plot Beats – Rise of the Guardians - Laura VanArendonk Baugh

  5. Pingback: Our Annual Christmas Movie, and Don't Argue With Me. - Laura VanArendonk Baugh

  6. I seem to have found this kind of late, but I have to say that I totally agree about not wanting things to be spoiled. For example, I was one of those odd people who did not play Final Fantasy VII right when it came out (I waited almost 15 years, as I wasn’t into video games as a child). As such, it bugged me to no end that the end of disc 1 had been spoiled for me by the famousness of the game. It was so masterfully done, and I just know that if it hadn’t been spoiled for me it would have had so much more of an impact with me. But sadly, it is pretty hard to escape spoilers for things that are that well known. In some ways, it makes it much harder to enjoy them.

  7. Pingback: People are Funny - Laura VanArendonk Baugh

  8. Pingback: What if Book Reviews and Author Interviews Ran Like Football Commentary? - Laura VanArendonk Baugh

  9. I SO agree with this. I’m in the NO SPOILER camp! I’ve had a few things accidentally spoiled for me (also see FFVII disk one ending, done by a GAME GUIDE that I accidentally opened to the wrong page to see a big picture spread of what happened). :(

    I don’t get people who spoil stuff willingly. I once had a person tell me “Well, things got spoiled for me, so I don’t care anymore and just blurt it out cause I *can*.” THAT. That sort of mentality I just don’t get.

  10. Me too, we must be weird… or that’s what they wanted we believe in.

    I hate the pictures netflix puts as backgrounds when a movie is loading, is like they have searched for the most key moment of the episode or movie to spoile the user..

  11. It’s sad that I have to point out that there’s indeed a spoiler on this page. I have never watched Princess Bride before- so thanks. I happen to be writing a speeh about spoilers; I’ll definitely include that.

    • pardon me- speech*

    • Not truly a spoiler: The pirate’s identity is unknown to the character Buttercup, but not to the viewing audience, as Cary Elwes clearly plays both and it’s pretty obviously set up as a fairy tale trope. The “reveal” isn’t a surprise to the viewer. (And anyway that’s still part of the setup, mere minutes into the film, so it’s not critical to the overall arc. It’s like saying Clark Kent and Superman are the same person, as a setup to a Superman story, which isn’t the story itself. That information is never a secret to the reader or viewer, only the other characters.)

      But you should watch the movie anyway, because it’s a good time. :)
      Laura recently posted…New Stories Coming!My Profile

  12. I understand, but all the same, I would rather watch a movie and figure that out by myself, rather than someone telling me something I \should\ know. I see where you are coming from, though.

  13. I absolutely LOVE spoilers. If I am really looking forward to a movie or new TV show, I will scout all over for the leaks. I’m also the girl who reads the last chapter of a book first. I know, I know! My mom taught me that trick. (Dad taught me to hunt down the mistakes/inconsistencies in movies. They are both a little weird.) While I love them, my best friend HATES spoilers, and I respect her preference. And she also knows that telling me some of the details about a book she just finished is the quickest way to get me to read it. She loves it though when I jump into a series (Like the Lunar Chronicles – gah!) without digging up and spoilers and hearing me scream that it wasn’t what I expected….and that I loved/hated it. =)

  14. I’m on the side that doesn’t mind spoilers. I don’t go looking for then, but if I get spoiled, it simply means I get to look at the writing itself and focus more on the HOW than the WHAT. I think it’s just a different way of enjoying those stories. I like saying that for me its always been the journey that’s been important, not the end point.

  15. Sometimes the spoilers make me want to read the story more.

  16. Oh, you guys are killing me! :D I am happy to look at how the author/screenwriter did it, definitely, but first I want to look at what they did.

    My MIL is one of those who won’t start a book without checking the end pages first, and if we watch a movie together she frequently asks what’s going to happen next or how it will end. I always lie. /evil grin/

    • Lol! I used to do that with books…read the last few pages…

    • No arguments. Just a difference in what we enjoy. My SO is on your side. He wants to see if he can see the tricks or hits coming before they do and knowing they’re coming means he didn’t get to prove himself. We all read for different reasons and like other things. I personally find how people read just as interesting as what and why. 😆

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

mention a recent post of your own?